Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd) header
Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd) profile picture

Senior Writer @NRO. author of My Father Left Me Ireland. Making sense of the disruptive politics of the 21st century.

Joined November 2007
Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)Photo by Michael Brendan Dougherty (@michaelbd)
Hinton's philosophical functionalism is what misleads him here. "Understanding" for a functionalist isn't distinguishable from the act of tracking patterns well enough to predict the outcome usefully. So he has no model for intellection beyond "Performs this task" and so what "falls apart" for him is a distinction he never really believed in to begin with. For Aristotle or Aquinas, understanding is an intellect grasping what a thing is.
Geoffrey Hinton: The argument that LLMs are just predicting the next word falls apart when you test their ability to understand something they've never seen before. “I have a former graduate student who's very smart and a very good programmer. And he did a little experiment.” “He defined a new programming language with very unusual syntax.” “He then gave it a program and said, what would this do? And it answered correctly.” “It could understand the definition of a new programming language and figure out what programs in that language would do.” “The idea that it's just predicting the next word doesn't make any sense in that context.” “It had to understand what was going on.”
1
2
6
1,510
AI Doomerism is the Population Bomb of our day.
8
5
61
3,151
The lacrosse thing is very interesting socially. Kind of an internal “flight” from more racially diverse and more competitive soccer.
If your kid is playing an international sport ie water polo, volleyball, soccer etc etc -- your kid is competing against the RoTW. If your kid is playing an indigenous American sport ie football, lacrosse -- your kid is competing against (mostly) Americans.
1
1
19
4,620
Told you
NEWS: Wall Street execs and NSA have told Congress that outages were caused by patching vulnerabilities identified by AI models, sources say AI did not cause outages but found so many issues that the rush to fix them before an attack overwhelmed systems washingtonsun.com/technology…
6
5
1
43
6,706
Weird, between this and the New York Magazine piece I haven’t seen one of these voters mention the MOU as their reason for turning against Republicans.
The most revealing line in this WSJ autopsy of Texas, imo, is the one at the very end from a Republican in Starr County, the 97-percent Hispanic border county that voted Trump in 2024 and promptly swung 76 points left to back Talarico. "'The betrayal was everything—the war and the gas and the fajitas,' Saenz said about rising costs. 'I still voted red, but in my heart I knew other people would vote blue.'" That word, "betrayal," gets at the hardest part of turning things around for 2028. People who swung Republican in 2024 were excited because they believed they were backing a GOP that had firmly and permanently rejected the elective wars of the Bush era and was ready to be focused only on America. To these people, the Iran war is not simply a mistake. It was, truly, a betrayal: The complete opposite of what they had been promised, and done with minimal justification. (And yes, I know that Donald Trump has always vowed Iran wouldn't get a nuclear weapon -- I'm simply describing how these voters saw things) From there, it was inevitable that those voters would see higher gas prices and other economic difficulties not as temporary difficulties necessary for the Administration to fulfill its promises, but as the immediate harms caused by a lie they fell for. Unsurprisingly, millions of people who felt this way stayed home, or switched their votes. It will be very difficult to win these people back. wsj.com/politics/elections/r…
25
19
2
180
21,200
The age old dream of ending politics is revolting, but this particular vision is so proudly ignorant and credulous I would prefer the old Stalinism to the new AI version. astralcodexten.com/p/against…
4
1
16
3,670
How can anyone honestly believe that everyone will just agree that the software is more charming and humble than a human while simultaneously approving of its “immutable” application of the power of life and death? Has the author met people?
14
1,579
My marker: you’re confusing people locking open doors with robbers trying to break in. Yes AI equipped tools can make hackers more dangerous, but AI’s record so far is that we’re solving technical debt and covering existing vulnerabilities and fixes for them. (PHP’s patch was nearly done when humans blabbed about it and gave black hats an opportunity)
3
4
1
29
6,904
My bet: As with the PHP incident a few weeks back, my bet is that actually AI helped people discover an existing widespread vulnerability. And that AI is helping us patch it. The problem with the PHP fix wasn’t AI, but that humans involved leaked the vulnerability and allowed hackers a window of opportunity that was in the process of being shut. The problem is that the media doesn’t want to say AI is helping us solve long existing tech debt, so people just remember “The PHP thing, something bad with AI happened.”
Weird but we still can’t rule out the possibility that everything breaking at once has been a string of coincidences that has nothing to do with AI
4
10
2
56
8,476
The idea that Iran went from the edge of defeat to completely rearmed and rallied during the short MOU period while we admit it will take maybe half a decade to rearm from our side is so risible I can’t believe anyone is saying it.
.@TomCottonAR on ending the Iran war by winning or surrendering. Democrats are poised to pressure Trump to do the latter.
28
98
6
789
52,757
“Muse, can you retrieve government UFO secrets for me.” Muse: “Working on it!” Two hours later:
We break: The highly classified network that the National Security Agency uses for its internal communications is down, according to five people familiar with the matter. The network, called NSA Net, allows employees to communicate classified information internally. At this point there is no evidence of a cyberattack, sources said. As the agency works to understand the scope of the problem, it has enacted staggered arrivals for personnel, the sources said. CNN has asked the National Security Agency for comment. cnn.com/2026/11/17/politics/…
1
3
49
4,676
One unflattering reason the GOP is nowhere on healthcare reform. Their typical idea would be to partner with some major industry or incumbent interest to help write legislation. But pharma, insurers, and hospital systems already got their bill from Obama's ACA. The last time they tried in 2017, they came up with tax cuts and Medicaid rollback and it couldn't pass in part because hospitals would have screamed.
19
11
10
122
22,526
Michael Brendan Dougherty retweeted
This is why I don’t get worked up about the “manosphere.”
26% of young Republican men blame their problems on women. 66% of young Democratic women blame their problems on men. 🔗 americansurveycenter.org/sig…
7
76
6
822
53,968
The only part missing is when the brother or brothers load resentment on the sister for living in their parents house for free.
SNL is patchy but when it’s good…
37
165
7
3,405
59,077
Cannot be helped.
Mike Pence on Iran: The overwhelming majority of the American people supported Operation Epic Fury and were inspired by our military. I don't think it's opposition to the war, but it was the fact that we stopped.
16
4
124
9,711