Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell) header
Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell) profile picture

Geographer. Prof at Temple University. Author of 2 books. Elephants. Maps. Archaeofuturist Transportation.

Philadelphia, USA
Joined December 2016
Photo by Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell)Photo by Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell)Photo by Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell)Photo by Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell)Photo by Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell)Photo by Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell)Photo by Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell)Photo by Jacob Shell (@JacobAShell)
Can't stop staring at this GIF of the lower mantle's anomalous slow-wave mega-blobs...which might be last remnants of the paleo-planet Theia which collided with proto-Earth 4.5 billion years ago to create "our" Earth and the Moon.
13
64
6
756
81,018
Yes but quarantines + surveillance are literally the primary topics of the Panopticon chapter of Discipline and Punish. Is that chapter just mysteriously skipped now? I dont see how anyone could read that chapter and not instantly perceive the implicit critique of quarantine maximalist regimes during COVID, e.g. in Australia where they dragged people to camps.
Replying to @JacobAShell
Selective application is the real issue. The framework gets used when it lines up with existing priorities (prisons, policing, certain kinds of capitalism) and gets quietly set aside the moment it would mean looking at the university’s own recent disciplinary techniques. The tools only get applied in directions that don’t challenge current admin practices or consensus views. Same pattern with land acknowledgments. They’re a low-cost, ritualized critique of historical settler power that institutions happily encourage, precisely because they leave the university’s current methods completely untouched. Emerson said a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds; this looks more like a very consistent refusal to turn the tools on the institution itself. Your point exactly.
2
1
21
682
It's just funny that D & P is still so aggressively promoted, but then the same institution promoting it also demands everybody spend 2020-22 quarantining (the main thing the famous "Panopticon" chapter critiques is the quarantine), and then spends 2023-26 demanding everybody upload all their work to the Infinite Surveillance and Labor Theft Website. Like, the failure, or self-betrayal, of the academic Foucauldians is just extraordinary. What do people even talk about in those classes where D & P is assigned, since critiques of COVID quarantines and Canvas-enforced "accessibility" rules are surely off-limits? Critiquing the things Foucault would have critiqued is forbidden, and therefore...everybody just sits around blinking at one another in silence for 90 minutes?
Grok says Foucault’s Discipline and Punish has been on Columbia’s Contemporary Civilization (CC) syllabus for decades. It’s documented in sections as early as Spring 2006 and has been a standard late-semester reading throughout the 2010s and current lists (typically in the spring half, under modern critique/power or anti-colonialism themes). Grok also notes CC is the Core’s political/social theory sequence, not the Literature Humanities “great books” literature track.
3
4
31
1,289
Everyone in the 2020s university is simultaneously required to do two things: 1) Read Foucault's Discipline and Punish 2) Upload literally EVERYTHING THEY DO onto this shiny new Infinite Surveillance Site.
2
5
60
1,320
My issue with the left's critique of AI is that it's too opportunistic and narrow. It's random local NIMBYism against large warehouses. The actual thing that needs to be discussed is the **infinite labor theft**, and the question of how everybody is to be compensated.
5
21
948
When the pandemic lockdowns began, the philosopher Giorgio Agamben warned that they could pose an extinction-level event for a type of human “communal life.” This was misinterpreted to mean restaurants and bars and other such commercial things, or maybe to spaces for political protests. And so the misunderstood warning was easily dismissed—since of course restaurants recovered (and the pro-lockdown faction prided itself as having superior culinary taste anyway); and there have been lots of protests over various issues. But Agamben was referring to something more hidden and subtle, a “communal life” that existed in a nonsurveilled, nondigital, spontaneous, sometimes shadowy or “illegal” way. “Communal life” in the sense of people breaking the rules the “Gesellschaft” has taught them about how to behave, and instead engaging in a “Gemeinschaft” that emerges from instinct, creativity and desire. And yes I think that in a lot of cities, that existed right up until 2020, and then it died and it never really came back. Agamben was right.
17
137
12
1,310
38,934
Jacob Shell retweeted
Zoom may have seemed at first like it had potential to be an intellectually productive technology, allowing academics to participate in meetings or even run classes while in the research field…but there are fewer resources for travel now! Everybody is just zooming from home, not from some remote research frontier. Zoom has gone hand in hand with a yanking of normal travel supports, so the academic travel that could have justified Zoom isnt even happening in the 2020s.
1
1
21
1,011
The degree to which important in-person academic events (dissertation defenses etc), which had once played an important intellectual role, have faded into “zoom meeting” status, definitely contributes an uneasy and gnawing sense of ambient fakery.
Um deles: Antes de 2020, o pessoal do mestrado/doutorado se reunia presencialmente pra fazer grupo de estudos. Hoje, por ser mais conveniente e gastar menos com deslocamento, é tudo online. O mesmo vale pra bancas de defesa. Dificilmente vejo uma sendo 100% presencial.
8
5
1
295
7,077
Zoom may have seemed at first like it had potential to be an intellectually productive technology, allowing academics to participate in meetings or even run classes while in the research field…but there are fewer resources for travel now! Everybody is just zooming from home, not from some remote research frontier. Zoom has gone hand in hand with a yanking of normal travel supports, so the academic travel that could have justified Zoom isnt even happening in the 2020s.
1
1
21
1,011
Btwn 2006 ("20 yrs ago") and today, the "reaction against the left" party has been in power half the time. They didn't do anything to stop or slow down the technosocial trends which many find dehumanizing (intensified surveillance grid, cynical gamification of social life, etc)
Replying to @dj5law @JacobAShell
The way out is easy: just stop voting left. You want the nice life that existed even just 20 years ago? Roll back the clock. It’s the ascendancy of leftists (and their complete inversion of reality) that has resulted in our shared reality being inverted into the ground.
10
7
132
3,530
@grok of the last 20 years, how many of those years have the Republicans been in control of A) the White House B) the Senate C) the House D) the Governorships E) how many of those years was the Supreme Court liberal vs centrist vs conservative
2
5
455
The literary prizes--which still exist for some reason--want to give prizes to African authors, which is fine, that's their prerogative. What's amazing about these cases is the prize committees can't be bothered use detection tools to make sure they're rewarding a real author!
Replying to @TuhinChakr
There is no dearth of remarkably talented African authors. And its very obvious that AI detectors won’t flag their books. If they did such technology ought to be burned to ground. But to my knowledge, there is no extant research showing that state of art AI detection programs are racially biased. (4/n)
1
18
1,008
I am 100% sure that if they asked "whats best recent novel authored by an African who didnt use AI?" they'd find authors, theyd find real people, theyd get to a short list. Do they not use detection tools because, unlike me, they actually don't think theyd find a single person??
1
233
I was curious about this. The "Brazilian" case is all the Wright bros' planes prior to the Santos-Dumont 1906 demo were taking off from a rail/catapult system, so they "dont count," even tho once launched they were definitely flying (Wright bros' 1905 Flyer III 40 mins airborne)
So apparently Brazil legitimately teaches that the Wright Brothers didn't invent the airplane. This might be nuttier than denying the moon landing. The Wrights documented their invention quite well.
11
2
80
3,849
So...yes it's gerrymandering the definition of "true flight" in a preposterous way to get the petty nationalist outcome they want. Santos-Dumont (half French btw) sounds like a major innovator though. Americans could probably learn more about non-American inventors.
4
22
799
Every single Mike Davis "Ecology of Fear" characterization of L.A. taken as hyperbole at the time turning out to be 100% accurate prediction (he had the Palisades burning down too).
Massive Geyser of Rotting Trash Erupted in LA Routine drilling at Chiquita Canyon landfill released a towering geyser of decomposing garbage and methane gas about 500 feet into the air. Just another day in LA 🤣
8
6
1
86
3,043
Remarkable how many little perks of academic lifestyle vanished after 2020.
27
30
9
2,077
145,077
Jacob Shell retweeted
A lot of the “smart classroom” gear is not only proving to be a waste of money, it’s literally a physical obstacle that makes rooms perform badly as discussion or paper test-taking spaces. And it introduces AI consoles into spaces where AI undermines pedagogy. In many cases the “smart classroom” gear should simply be removed—but that would involve the people who blew so much money on it (money that could have gone into scholarships, research, etc) admitting that it was a mistake.
2
12
586
Uni leaders dont want to talk about how attractive & logical the “low-tech strategy” suddenly looks, because it would require admitting that blowing so much of the budget last decade on “smart classrooms” (jampacked full of computer gear on every last square inch) was a bad idea.
Yeah, a lot of these things would be quite easy to enforce if you went deliberately low-tech, which a residential liberal arts college could do relatively easily. Bring back the 24-hour computer lab, ban personal laptops, ban smartphones.
9
14
105
2,247
A lot of the “smart classroom” gear is not only proving to be a waste of money, it’s literally a physical obstacle that makes rooms perform badly as discussion or paper test-taking spaces. And it introduces AI consoles into spaces where AI undermines pedagogy. In many cases the “smart classroom” gear should simply be removed—but that would involve the people who blew so much money on it (money that could have gone into scholarships, research, etc) admitting that it was a mistake.
2
12
586